PIE FLAVORS | Gardner Pie

Pie Redefined.

It’s not just for holidays. Pie is for big celebrations and small milestones. Whatever the reason, pie makes it sweeter.

See What's Baking

for the
Young
at
Heart

Looking for ingredients?

Have allergies?

Curious about nutrition facts?

Check the Fact Sheet

Delightful Pies

Quality you can taste, value you'll love.

The Delightful line is our value-tier offering, designed for customers seeking quality pies at a more affordable price point. These pies are made with the same care and attention to flavor as our standard line, but with a slightly thinner fruit layer to keep costs down. They’re a great option for budget-conscious shoppers who still want that classic Gardner Pie taste. Perfect for everyday dessert, family meals, or high-volume promotions, Delightful pies offer excellent margin potential without compromising satisfaction.

Strawberry Lemonade Pie

Diced strawberries coated in our unique lemon sugar and baked in our flaky crust that's topped with a lemon glaze. Sweet and tart – a perfect combination for the summer.

Dark Chocolate Cherry Pie

Dark chocolate chips blended with Montmorency cherries—"The cherries with more," wrapped in our flaky crust make this the perfect trio. Heart cutouts on our crust make this delicious pie one you will fall in love with.

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Red ripe strawberries and tart rhubarb are a classic combination. One taste of this old-fashioned favorite and you’ll remember why. This tasty treat is sure to boost pie sales, especially during early spring and summer.

Original
Delightful

Very Berry Pie

Our Very Berry pie uses only high quality fruits, including a proprietary blend of sweet strawberries, tender blueberries, blackberries and red raspberries.

Peach Blueberry Pie

East Coast meets west coast in this delicious pie featuring two favorite fruit flavors: blueberries and peaches. This classic pie is as refreshing as it is colorful, making it a great seasonal feature.

Apple Cranberry Pie

Our apple cranberry pie is a holiday favorite, delicious any time. A perfect combination of fresh apples and sliced, tart cranberries give this pie its distinctive flavor.

Apple Berry Delight Pie

Apple Berry Delight a Gardner kitchen exclusive brings together the best of summer’s offerings in every delightful bite. Crisp apple slices are paired with premium blackberries, raspberries, blueberries, strawberries and tart rhubarb. It’s a unique combination that is perfectly at home all year ’round.

Mango Strawberry Pie

~ Mango Strawberry ~

Hatch Green Chile Apple Pie

Hatch green chiles and sweet apples make this pie so unique you have to see for yourself how this has the perfect balance of sweet and spicy.

Caramel Apple Walnut Pie

We top our fresh apple pie with rich caramel and crunchy chopped walnuts for a dessert that’s decadently delicious. Just one bite and you’ll see why this apple pie is so special.

Original
Delightful

NJ Dutch Blueberry Pie

Packed with juicy blueberries and finished with a streusel topping, our Natural Juice Dutch Blueberry Pie is bursting with flavor. The sweet crumb topping adds a light crunch that perfectly complements the bright berry layer.

NJ Peach Crisp Pie

Fresh California peaches give this pie its delicious fruit flavor, but our sweet crumb topping makes it extra special. The topping adds an unexpected crunch that is perfect with the juicy fruit filling, for a refreshing and tasty treat.

Churro Apple Pie

Our Churro Apple Pie blends a sweet & slightly spicy cinnamon sugar crumb topping with our delicious flaky crust. This recipe will melt in your mouth, guaranteed to become your new favorite. It's delectable served warm with ice cream.

Blueberry Lemon Buckle Pie

We use large, juicy blueberries to make this classic dessert. Topped with sugary, lemon crumb topping, our blueberry lemon buckle pie offers the perfect balance of sweetness and tartness in every delicious bite.

NJ Dutch Apple Granny Smith Pie

Tart Granny Smith apples bring a bold twist to this classic favorite. Layered with a hint of cinnamon and topped with our sweet, crunchy streusel, it’s all baked into our signature flaky crust for a pie that’s deeply satisfying.

Peach Praline Pie

One taste and you’ll see why this pie is a southern tradition. We take fresh, sun-ripened peaches and top them with a rich praline topping and pieces of crunchy pecans for real down-home goodness.

NJ Apple Crisp Pie

A classic dessert dating back to Colonial America, our NJ Apple Crisp Pie features fresh sliced apples piled high in a tender crust. Our topping is a crunchy blend of spiced brown sugar and rolled oats for real old-fashioned flavor.

NJ Cherry Crumb Pie

Our signature flaky crust filled with super grade “A” whole, red tart cherries and finished with a lightly sweetened, white crumb topping. Often described as “pure yumminess”, this pie will be a sure fire hit when you want to serve the best.

Peach Melba Pie

This pie is a delicious blend of fresh peaches and red raspberries, topped with our delicate raspberry sauce and almond slivers, for a flavor and texture that’s second to none.

NJ Dutch Apple Pie

A classic blend of our fresh, sliced apples and a delicious streusel topping with a hint of cinnamon. A recipe with its heritage dating back to the Pennsylvania Dutch, will be a sure fire hit when warmed and topped with fresh whipped cream.

Pineapple Upside Down Pie

We’ve taken the flavors of the classic cake and turned them into a one-of-a-kind pie.

Pina Colada Pie

Take your tastebuds on a tropical getaway with our Pina Colada Pie. Made with juicy pineapple and sweetened coconut, it’s a smooth, sunshine-sweet blend baked into our golden, flaky crust. Finished with coconut glaze for just the right island touch.

Apple Pie

What’s more American than apple pie? At the Gardner Pie Company, we use only fresh Ida Red apples, with real sugar and a hint of cinnamon. You’re guaranteed the freshest fruit taste in every bite.

Original
Delightful
NSA Delightful
Harvest

Blackberry Pie

Our blackberries are hand-selected and picked at the peak of ripeness, for the freshest fruit flavor. Served with a dollop of vanilla ice cream or by itself, our blackberry pie is a tasty treat all year long.

Original
Delightful

Cherry Pie

We combine red cherries with our special sugar recipe for a pie that offers the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness. Because our cherries exceed USDA Grade A standards, a Gardner cherry pie is unmatched in quality and taste.

Original
Delightful
NSA Delightful

Peach Pie

Nothing says summer like homemade peach pie, and nothing is as close to homemade as a Gardner peach pie. Made with mounds of juicy and delicious California-grown peaches, our peach pie is brimming with fresh fruit flavor in every mouth-watering bite.

Original
Delightful

Wild Blueberry Pie

Made from sweet and tiny wild blueberries, this Gardner favorite is bursting with fruit flavor, as well as powerful anti-oxidants. Our wild blueberries are grown in Maine and Canada and selected for peak flavor and freshness.

Original
Delightful

Strawberry Pie

~ Strawberry Pie ~

Country Apple Cinnamon Pie

We add an extra pinch of cinnamon and brown sugar over fresh-cut apple slices for an extra-special version of our apple pie. This secret recipe has been a Gardner family favorite for years. It’s sure to become a customer favorite as well.

Black Cherry Pie

~ Black Cherry Pie ~

Honey Crisp Apple Pie

~ Honey Crisp Apple ~

Red Raspberry Pie

Red raspberries and our special sugar recipe create the perfect blend of tartness and sweetness, while enhancing the fresh fruit flavor of plump red raspberries. These sun-ripened gems are primarily grown in Washington State and carefully chosen for their delicate and delicious taste.

Granny Smith Apple Pie

~ Granny Smith Apple Pie ~

Lemon Blueberry Pie

~ Lemon Blueberry ~

French Apple Pie

~ French Apple Pie ~

Pumpkin Pie

Following a recipe that's been in our family for years, this holiday favorite is full of pumpkin and a secret blend of spices. Because this creamy and flavorful dessert is so popular, we offer it all year round.

Original
Shelf Stable

Pumpkin Spice Latte Pie

Everyone's favorite fall drink has been made into a new cozy dessert! Spiced pumpkin custard filling made extra rich with decadent swirls of cream and infused with espresso, baked in our signature flaky crust.

Pecan Pie

A rich blend of brown sugar, syrup, eggs and pecans gives this sweet custard pie it's traditional southern flavor. An old-fashioned favorite, our pecan pie is always a popular choice for holidays and other special occasions.

Original
Chocolate Chip Pecan

Sweet Potato Pie

We've combined a rich, buttery blend of sweet potatoes with the perfect amount of ginger and nutmeg. The result is a delicious southern classic that never goes out of style.

Original
Shelf Stable

Sweet Potato Crunch Pie

What happens when you add a crunchy topping of brown sugar, pecans and coconut to our classic Sweet Potato Pie? An amazing, new favorite pie.

Original
Shelf Stable

Colonial Apple Pie

What’s more American than apple pie? At Gardner Pie Company, we use only fresh Ida Red apples, with real sugar and a hint of cinnamon. You’re guaranteed the freshest fruit taste in every bite.

Mini
Regular

Mini Colonial Very Berry Pie

Four different types of berries go into every Very Berry pie. Fresh strawberries, red raspberries, blueberries and blackberries add their own distinctive flavor and sweetness in this delicious long-standing customer favorite.

Colonial Apple Red Raspberry Pie

We’ve added red raspberries to our one-of-a-kind Colonial Apple Pie for a twist on the delicious fruit filling. Weighing in at four-pounds, this handmade pie is wrapped in our tender, flaky crust, which gives it its distinctive, rustic look.

Pie Redefined.

Check the Fact Sheet

Delightful Pies

Quality you can taste, value you'll love.

Apple Pie

Blackberry Pie

Cherry Pie

Peach Pie

Wild Blueberry Pie

Strawberry Pie

Country Apple Cinnamon Pie

Black Cherry Pie

Honey Crisp Apple Pie

Red Raspberry Pie

Granny Smith Apple Pie

Lemon Blueberry Pie

French Apple Pie

Pie Questions?