PIE CATEGORIES

Click the category below for info on your favorite pie!

Click here for
BAKING & HANDLING VIDEO

Click here for
BAKING & HANDLING INSTRUCTIONS

Click here for
KOSHER CERTIFICATES

FRUIT PIES

Fruit Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

APPLE

Made with fresh Ida Red apples, real sugar and a hint of cinnamon. You’re guaranteed the freshest fruit taste in every bite.

BLACKBERRY

Our blackberries are hand-selected and picked at the peak of ripeness, for the freshest fruit flavor.

BLUEBERRY

Made from sweet and tiny wild blueberries, our wild blueberries are grown in Maine and Canada and selected for peak flavor and freshness.

BOYSENBERRY

The boysenberry combines the tartness of blackberries with the sweetness of red raspberries tucked into our buttery and flaky double crust.

CHERRY

We combine red cherries with our special sugar recipe for a pie that offers the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness.

COUNTRY APPLE CINNAMON

We add an extra pinch of cinnamon and brown sugar over fresh-cut apple slices for an extra-special version of our apple pie.

PEACH

Made with mounds of juicy and delicious California-grown peaches, our peach pie is brimming with fresh fruit flavor in every mouth-watering bite.

RED RASPBERRY

Red raspberries and our special sugar recipe create the perfect blend of tartness and sweetness, while enhancing the fresh fruit flavor of plump red raspberries.

RHUBARB

Made with a combination of vibrant red and green rhubarb and sweetened with real cane sugar, this pie offers the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness in every delicious bite.

STRAWBERRY

The best baked strawberry pie on the market starts with fresh, hand-picked California strawberries for a pie that’s loaded with real berry flavor.

TOPPED PIES

The perfect pie, with a little something on top!

Topped Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

APPLE BROWN BETTY

Our topping is a crunchy blend of spiced brown sugar and rolled oats for real old-fashioned flavor.

CARAMEL APPLE WALNUT

We top our fresh apple pie with rich caramel and crunchy chopped walnuts for a dessert that’s decadently delicious.

APPLE CRISP

A rich flaky crust filled with fresh, sliced apples. Gracefully finished with a crumb topping of rolled oats and brown sugar.

BLUEBERRY LEMON BUCKLE

Topped with sugary, lemon crumb topping, our blueberry lemon buckle pie offers the perfect balance of sweetness and tartness in every delicious bite.

CHERRY CRUMB

Our signature flaky crust filled with super grade “A” whole, red tart cherries and finished with a lightly sweetened, white crumb topping.

CHERRY VANILLA

Sweet vanilla cream sauce is a perfect addition to our classic cherry pie, while sliced almonds add texture, crunch and a nutty flavor that’s just right.

LEMON BLUEBERRY

Wild Maine blueberries meet lemon glaze in this flavor combination that’s light as a summer’s day.

DUTCH APPLE

A classic blend of our fresh, sliced apples and a delicious streusel topping with a hint of cinnamon.

PEACH CRISP

Fresh California peaches give this pie its delicious fruit flavor, but our sweet crumb topping makes it extra special.

PEACH MELBA

A delicious blend of fresh peaches and red raspberries, topped with our delicate raspberry sauce and almond slivers.

PEACH PRALINE

We take fresh, sun-ripened peaches and top them with a rich praline topping and pieces of crunchy pecans for real down-home goodness.

PINEAPPLE UPSIDE DOWN

Tart cherries and chunks of sweet pineapple are smothered in a homemade brown sugar sauce and chopped pecans.

BLUEBERR LEMON BUCKLE ANCHOR

A handmade pie with a homemade flavor!

COLONIAL PIES

Colonial Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

COLONIAL APPLE

This handmade, four-pound pie is packed with fresh Ida Red apples, sprinkled with a special recipe of cinnamon sugar.

COLONIAL APPLE CRANBERRY

Tart, Premium-Select Wisconsin cranberries are in perfect harmony with sweet Ida Red apples. Like all of our Colonial Pies, this hearty treat weighs in at four pounds.

COLONIAL APPLE RAISIN

Plump, juicy California raisins add an extra hint of sweetness to this hearty favorite.

COLONIAL APPLE RED RASPBERRY

We’ve added red raspberries to our one-of-a-kind Colonial Apple Pie for a twist on the delicious fruit filling.

MINI COLONIAL APPLE

At Gardner Pie Company, we use only fresh Ida Red apples, with real sugar and a hint of cinnamon.

MINI COLONIAL PEACH

Made with mounds of juicy and delicious California-grown peaches.

MINI COLONIAL PEACH BLUEBERRY

Sweet blueberries are paired with mounds of juicy, fresh peaches for a pie that’s loaded with real fruit flavor.

MINI COLONIAL VERY BERRY

Fresh strawberries, red raspberries, blueberries and blackberries add their own distinctive flavor and sweetness.

Fewer ingredients, same great flavor!

NON-GMO / CLEAN LABEL

NON-GMO Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

NON-GMO APPLE

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, featuring fresh IDA Red Apples. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO APPLE WALNUT

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including organic butter, fresh apples and California Walnuts. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO CHERRY

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including Super Grade A Michigan Tart Cherries. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO CINNAMON APPLE

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including fresh apples and real cinnamon. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO PINEAPPLE UPSIDE DOWN

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including organic butter, sweet pineapple tidbits, cherries and pecans. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO PEACH

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including tree -ripened peaches. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO STRAWBERRY RHUBARB

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including a proprietary blend of sweet strawberries and tart rhubarb. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO VERY BERRY

This clean label pie uses only high quality fruits, including a proprietary blend of sweet strawberries, tender blueberries, blackberries and red raspberries. Non-GMO Project Verified.

NON-GMO WILD BLUEBERRY

This clean label pie uses only high quality ingredients, including tender, sweet wild blueberries. Non-GMO Project Verified.

Good things come in small packages!

DESSERTS FOR TWO

6" Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

6" BLUEBERRY LEMON BUCKLE

Full-sized berries are topped with sugary, lemon crumb topping to create a treat that’s guaranteed to brighten any day.

6" APPLE

Just like our full size pies, this 6” pie is made with fresh Ida Red apples, with real sugar and a hint of cinnamon.

6" APPLE BROWN BETTY

Fresh sliced apples piled high in a petite tender crust. A healthy dose of spiced brown sugar and oats topping adds crunch, flavor and interest.

6" CARAMEL APPLE WALNUT

Rich caramel and crunchy chopped walnuts for a dessert that’s decadently delicious.

6" BLACKBERRY

Our blackberries are hand-selected and picked at the peak of ripeness, for the freshest fruit flavor.

6" BLUEBERRY

Made from sweet and tiny wild blueberries, this miniature classic is bursting with fruit flavor, as well as powerful anti-oxidants.

6" CHERRY

Cherries that exceed USDA Grade A standards ensure every bite of this petite pie is loaded with flavor.

6" NSA APPLE

Our traditional apple pie, made from fresh Ida Red apples, has been modified for the health-conscious or restricted-diet consumer with Gardner’s special no-sugar blend.

6" PEACH

We’ve scaled back the size, but kept the flavor big by including mounds of tree-ripened peaches that bake in their own juice.

6" PEACH CRISP

This little beauty is filled with the best California has to offer, then sprinkled with a crunchy sweet crumb topping.

6" PECAN

A rich blend of brown sugar, eggs and pecans gives this pie its traditional flavor. Our pecan pie is always a popular choice for holidays.

6" PINEAPPLE UPSIDE DOWN

Tart cherries and chunks of sweet pineapple smothered in a homemade brown sugar sauce, tucked inside our 6” signature crust and topped with chopped Pecans.

6" SHELF STABLE PUMPKIN

Quality pumpkin meets a secret blend of spices for a creamy and flavorful dessert that will certainly bring out the holiday cheer.

6" STRAWBERRY RHUBARB

Red ripe strawberries and tart rhubarb are a classic combination.

6" VERY BERRY

Fresh strawberries, red raspberries, blueberries and blackberries add their own distinctive flavor and sweetness to this delicious pie that’s always a hit.

Old fashioned recipe with a bit of spice!

SOUTH OF THE BORDER

South of the Border Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

CHERRY LIME

This unique pie is an interesting combination of the tartness of fresh red cherries and a rich and buttery key lime sauce provides the perfect complement to both distinct flavors.

SPICY HABANERO PEACH

Sweet California peaches are paired with hot and spicy habañero pepper flakes in this unexpected flavor combination.

JALAPENO APPLE

We took our popular apple pie and gave it an extra kick with diced red and green jalapeño peppers and a rich caramel sauce baked right into the filling.

MANGO STRAWBERRY

Golden tropical mangos and ripe red strawberries are both delicious summertime fruits, so it makes sense they’d go so well together.

PINA COLADA

We use chunks of fresh pineapple in a tender, flaky crust, all covered by a creamy coconut topping and baked to a golden brown.

RED RASPBERRY LIME

Bursting with tropical flavor, this pie combines sweet red raspberries, ripened to perfection, with a delicate Persian lime topping.

A multitude of fruit and flavor!

MIXED FRUIT PIES

Mixed Fruit Pie Anchor 1

( Click the Pictures below for Product Info. )

APPLE BERRY DELIGHT

Apple Berry Delight a Gardner kitchen exclusive brings together the best of summer’s offerings in every delightful bite. Crisp apple slices are paired with premium blackberries, raspberries, blueberries, strawberries and tart rhubarb. It’s a unique combination that is perfectly at home all year ’round..

APPLE CRANBERRY

Our apple cranberry pie is a holiday favorite, delicious any time. A perfect combination of fresh apples and sliced, tart cranberries give this pie its distinctive flavor.

APPLE RASPBERRY

Fresh apples are paired with red raspberries in this Gardner favorite. The red raspberries add just a hint of color and a touch of sweetness to make this pie a holiday classic.

PEACH BLUEBERRY

East Coast meets west coast in this delicious pie featuring two favorite fruit flavors: blueberries and peaches. This classic pie is as refreshing as it is colorful, making it a great seasonal feature.

STRAWBERRY RHUBARB

Red ripe strawberries and tart rhubarb are a classic combination. One taste of this old-fashioned favorite and you’ll remember why. This tasty treat is sure to boost pie sales, especially during early spring and summer.

VERY BERRY

Four different types of berries go into every Very Berry pie. Fresh strawberries, red raspberries, blueberries and blackberries add their own distinctive flavor and sweetness in this delicious long-standing customer favorite.

The right pie for the right occasion!

FRUIT PIES

SEASONAL PIES

COLONIAL PIES

NO SUGAR ADDED PIES

NON-GMO / CLEAN LABEL

HARVEST EDITION PIES

DESSERTS FOR TWO

SAVORY VEGETABLES PIES

SOUTH OF THE BORDER

MIXED FRUIT PIES

TOPPED PIES

PIE CATEGORIES

FRUIT PIES

TOPPED PIES

COLONIAL PIES

NON-GMO / CLEAN LABEL

DESSERTS FOR TWO

SOUTH OF THE BORDER

MIXED FRUIT PIES

SEASONAL PIES