top of page

The Proof
is in 
the Pie

More fruit to ensure the best flavor.
Pumpkin_HIRES (1).jpg


Crafted from Pumpkin aged to perfection, our pie will remind your guests why family and traditions are important and delicious! Serve warm or cold with your favorite topping to make it your own.

Natural juice Apple Crisp

A classic dessert dating back
to Colonial America, previously named Apple Brown Betty, our Apple Crisp features fresh sliced apples piled high in a tender crust. Our topping is a crunchy blend of spiced brown sugar and rolled oats for real old-fashioned flavor.

A Gardner Pie Apple Brown Betty Pie
A bowl of blueberries


- Real Cane and Beet Sugar

- No High Fructose Corn Syrup

- No Artificial Flavors

- Original Natural Juice

- Premium Spices

- Clean Label


Natural Juice PEACH CRISP

Did you know that tree ripened peaches give the best flavor?


This little beauty is filled with the best tree ripened peaches, then sprinkled with a crunchy sweet crumb topping. It’s a taste of summer that’s just the right size for sharing.

Baking Ingredients: Eggs, Butter, Flour etc...

The Original 
Natural Juice Pie!

Bowls of cinnamon, water, sugar, flour, butter, salt and blueberries

Nothing but the good stuff



The Best




Real Cane


A Splash

Water (Crust)

A Pinch of


Locally Sourced


What's in those pies?
A rolling pin, eggs flour and dough balls

Without a great crust you don't have a great pie

Our signature flaky crust is made
in small batches to ensure tenderness. 

The Favorites
Slice of Gardner's Blueberry Lemon Buckle Pie on a Plate
A Gardner apple brown betty pie
Blueberry Lemon Buckle
NJ Apple Crisp

   Only the finest ingredients

and lots of them!

"We learned years ago that the best way
to compete in a crowded marketplace is to produce
a product second to none."

-Tom Gardner

What's New!

bottom of page